Claude Bernard, critique d’Hippocrate
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.55595/makanisi.2022.n5.54Keywords:
éthique, maladie, médecine naturaliste, médecine expérimentale, thérapies naturalistesAbstract
The medical sciences were rebuilt in the 5th century BC on the basis of a methodological revolution brought about by Hippocrates. The challenge for the doctor from Cos was to resize the theoretical framework of medical practice by rejecting its magico -religious language in favor of observation and expectation. It was a feat that resounded until the 19th century before being challenged by Claude Bernard. For the latter, medicine, the most important science of humanity, is condemned to remain expectant and inoperat ive without the possibility of progress if it remains in naturalism and observation. He therefore proposes a more conquering and operative experimental medicine which aims to act on the disease to cure it from its deterministic conditions of manifestation. Consequently, this laboratory medicine, which only considers quantitative and measurable biological data, has put the subjective and anthropological dimension of the disease on the index. This poses today ethical problems that call for the reconsideration of Hippocratic medical holism and, by extension, for naturalistic therapies.